Is It a Red Flag If Your Partner Hates Valentine’s Day?

Every February 14th, like clockwork, Valentine’s Day shows up with its roses, heart-shaped balloons, suspiciously overpriced chocolates, and couples doing the absolute most online. And just as predictably, there’s always that one person who rolls their eyes and says, “Valentine’s Day is a scam.”

Read Next: Valentine on a budget: ₦10,000 date ideas for lovers. 

If that person happens to be your partner, you might find yourself wondering," Is this a red flag? Should I be worried? Are they emotionally unavailable? Anti-love? Or just anti-capitalism with a sprinkle of trauma?

Let’s talk about it.

Read Next: 80 Love messages you can send to your partner on Valentine's Day

Contrary to social media wisdom, not everything is a red flag. Some things are just preferences.

A lot of people dislike Valentine’s Day for reasons that have nothing to do with their ability to love or commit. Some see it as overly commercial. Others hate being pressured to perform romance on a specific date. 

Some people are private lovers who don’t like public displays of affection or forced romance. And some (wholly, thoroughly and extremely single individuals) are just tired of Instagram couples acting as if love expires at midnight.

For some people, Valentine’s Day is tied to painful memories: past heartbreaks, loss, rejection, or relationships where they felt unloved or pressured. The day can bring up feelings they haven’t fully processed, so avoidance becomes easier than vulnerability.

None of this automatically means your partner doesn’t care about you…depending on their actions. Stay with me till the end.

Read Next: Fallen Out of Love With Your Partner? Here’s What to Do 

For some people, love is in the everyday stuff: remembering your comfort snack, checking in when you’ve had a rough day, sending memes at 2 a.m., or showing up when it matters. Valentine’s Day, to them, feels performative. 

If your partner is thoughtful, consistent, affectionate, and emotionally present all year round, but simply doesn’t vibe with February 14th, that’s not a red flag. 

Read Next: Attachment Styles and Their Role in Relationships: Why You Love the Way You Do 

Now, let’s gently pivot.

If your partner hates Valentine’s Day and dismisses your feelings about it, that’s worth paying attention to. There’s a difference between “I don’t like Valentine’s Day” and “Valentine’s Day is stupid, and anyone who cares about it is shallow”.

One is a preference. The other is invalidation.

If you’ve expressed that the day matters to you, even a little, and they completely refuse to acknowledge that, compromise, or meet you halfway, that’s less about Valentine’s Day and more about emotional consideration.

Healthy relationships aren’t built on identical preferences; they’re built on mutual care. You don’t have to love the same things, but you should care about what matters to each other.

Read Next: Real Love vs Internet Love: Understanding the Signs of a Healthy Relationship 

Sometimes, a partner’s hatred for Valentine’s Day is wrapped up in bigger beliefs about love, vulnerability, or emotional expression. 

Phrases like “I’m not romantic”, “I don’t do all that love stuff”, or “Love is overrated” can sound radical, but they deserve clarification.

Are they saying this because they genuinely express love differently? Or because emotional intimacy makes them uncomfortable? I personally believe anyone who claims to be unromantic is not capable of love. 

So, context matters. “I hate Valentine’s Day” may not necessarily be a red flag, but it’s definitely a conversation starter. Ask them why.

Read Next: 10 Breakup Messages for Her (Written by a Man Who Has Seen Shege) 

Here’s the real tea: hating Valentine’s Day is not the issue. How your partner treats you around Valentine’s Day is important.

Do they:

• Mock or belittle you for caring so much about a single day of the year?

• Refuse any form of compromise?

• Use their hatred of the day as an excuse to show zero effort?

• Make you feel silly, needy, or dramatic for wanting romance?

If yes, then the red flag is vibrant, and you may be partnered with your enemy.

Read Next: 10 Breakup Messages for Him (That Say Exactly What You Mean) 

On the flip side, if they say, “I don’t like Valentine’s Day, but I know it matters to you, so let’s do something low-key,” that’s actually a green flag. It shows flexibility, consideration, and emotional maturity.

If your partner hates Valentine’s Day, here’s what you should do.

Instead of assuming they’re unromantic or unserious, ask why. Do they dislike the pressure? The spending? The social media performance? Sometimes it’s about discomfort, not indifference.

Don’t downplay your feelings to seem “chill”. If the day matters to you, say that clearly. Is it about romance? Effort? Feeling chosen? The clearer you are, the easier it is to find middle ground.

Maybe they hate the hype but don’t mind intentional time together. Suggest something low-pressure: cooking at home, exchanging thoughtful gifts, or celebrating on a different day.

If they dislike Valentine’s Day but show love consistently all year, you’re likely dealing with a preference. If they avoid effort altogether, on Valentine’s and beyond,  that’s a deeper issue.

You can compromise on the theatrics and themed gestures, but never compromise on feeling valued. Make sure you’re adjusting expectations, not shrinking your needs.

Yes. Different opinions aren’t the problem, but disrespect is. If both partners feel heard and are willing to compromise, the relationship can absolutely thrive.

Very normal. Some people dislike the commercial pressure, public expectations, or past emotional triggers tied to the day. It doesn’t automatically mean they’re anti-love.

It depends on the couple. For some, it’s meaningful and symbolic. For others, love is shown consistently year-round. The real importance lies in whether partners care about what matters to each other.

Not necessarily. While it may seem like men complain about Valentine’s Day more often, social trends show that dislike for the holiday isn’t strictly gender-based. Dislike for the holiday is more about personality, experiences, and expectations than gender.

This can feel personal, but it doesn’t automatically mean something is wrong. People change. Past experiences (good or bad) can shift how someone views the holiday. It’s best to have a conversation about it.

Yes. Refusing to celebrate is one thing. Refusing to compromise or show care for what matters to you is another. If they’re unwilling to meet you halfway, even with something small and thoughtful, then it’s a red flag.

Yes. Think of Jehovah's Witnesses who don’t celebrate Valentine’s Day. It’s ideal for them to create their own version to make their partners feel loved. That's what healthy couples do.

Some celebrate on a different day to avoid the pressure. 

Look beyond the day itself. Are there ongoing signs of emotional distance, avoidance, resentment, or lack of effort? Valentine’s can magnify existing cracks, but it rarely creates them.

At the end of the day, Valentine’s Day is just a symbol. What really matters is whether your partner shows up for you in ways that make you feel seen, valued, and chosen, either on February 14th or on random Tuesdays in July.