ADVERTISEMENT

Here's What Happened to Dr. Michael West From The Innocence Files

Each episode of the new Netflix docuseries The Innocence Files follows a different story of wrongful conviction, and the heartbreaking stories showcase how a deeply flawed criminal justice system can fail both the families of the wrongfully accused as well as the victims of crimes. The doc's title comes from the Innocence Project , a nonprofit organization that works to uncover and overturn wrongful convictions.

Here's What Happened to Dr. Michael West

The series breaks down its nine episodes into three different spotlights on The Evidence, The Witness and The Prosecution, and the first episode delves into how the evidence analysis provided by Dr. Michael West, a so-called "bite mark expert," has led to the wrongful conviction of more than a half dozen people .

Dr. Michael West is a dentist and forensic odontologist. Forensic odontology , or bite mark analysis, is "the application of dental science to legal investigations," and it became popular after the arrest and conviction of serial killer Ted Bundy . However, bite mark evidence can be imprecise, and in 2009 the National Academy of Sciences published a study that discredited using it as a means to identify and/or convict defendants.

West attended the Louisiana State University School of Dentistry and later studied forensic dentistry at the Armed Forces Institute of Pathology in Washington D.C. He rose to fame in the 1980s, and testified at numerous trials. His work would involve him taking teeth impressions from the accused person, then making molds to see if they matched the marks seen on the victim. However, that method, called "direct comparison" can be unreliable.

ADVERTISEMENT

As seen during The Innocence Files, Dr. West's bite mark testimony directly contributed to the murder convictions of Levon Brooks and Kennedy Brewer. Brooks and Brewer were accused of killing two young girls in the early 1990's, and while there wasn't much evidence tying either man to the crime, West concluded that the bite marks seen on the two girls came from Brooks and Brewer, respectively.

As Oxygen reports, West even went so far as to say that the marks seen on one of the victims were "indeed and without a doubt inflected [sic] by Kennedy Brewer." Both men served more than a decade in prison before being exonerated in 2008 after the girls real killer, Justin Albert Johnson, confessed to the murders. He had previously been ruled out as a suspect because West believed that his teeth didn't match the marks on the victims, but after he confessed, he denied biting the victims at all. It was later revealed that the marks West had inspected were actually crawfish bites that the victims had sustained from the pond that they were found in.

In 2009, it was reported that West had once forced a suspects dental mold into a corpse to make it fit, and David Averill, the former president of the American Board of Forensic Science said that West's actions were "troubling...there's just no justification for him to push the cast into the skin like that. That isn't an acceptable way to perform a bite mark analysis."

ADVERTISEMENT

Several of West's colleagues have also condemned his actions, and Dr Richard Souviron, the forensic odontologist who testified in the Ted Bundy trial, pointed out that West's models only focus on the upper parts of the mouth. Dr. Niki Osborne, a forensic research scientist, also told Oxygen that it was inappropriate for West to make such declarative statements on a suspected person's guilt.

West is 67, retired, and currently living in Hattiesburg, Mississippi. In a 2011 deposition, West said that he "no longer believes in bite-mark analysis. I dont think it should be used in court. I think you should use DNA. Throw bite marks out."

In 2012, two women named Leigh Stubbs and Tammy Vance were freed from prison after spending almost 11 years behind bars. They had been convicted in 2001 after West claimed he matched bite marks on a victims body to Stubbs and Vance.

However, it seems like West still believes in his work. He gave a lengthy statement to Oxygen in which he said he still thinks bite mark analysis is valid, but "amateur practitioners" don't know what they're doing. He also made a startling claim that he felt like he was being treated similarly to the confederate statues that are being removed in public places throughout the south: "Taking it away does not better anything," he said. "Erasing history is ignorant. It benefits no one. They want to erase me from history."

Enhance Your Pulse News Experience!

Get rewards worth up to $20 when selected to participate in our exclusive focus group. Your input will help us to make informed decisions that align with your needs and preferences.

I've got feedback!

JOIN OUR PULSE COMMUNITY!

Unblock notifications in browser settings.
ADVERTISEMENT

Eyewitness? Submit your stories now via social or:

Email: eyewitness@pulse.ng

Recommended articles

5 ways chamomile tea enhances your sexual health

5 ways chamomile tea enhances your sexual health

Okin biscuits and 9 other snacks millennials loved as children

Okin biscuits and 9 other snacks millennials loved as children

What to know about the pros and cons of using pregnancy test strips

What to know about the pros and cons of using pregnancy test strips

Top 10 richest men in Nigeria and their net worth

Top 10 richest men in Nigeria and their net worth

How to share and transfer data on Glo

How to share and transfer data on Glo

'How the cleaning lady saved my marriage from collapsing'

'How the cleaning lady saved my marriage from collapsing'

10 body language signs that show she's attracted to you

10 body language signs that show she's attracted to you

Kenkey lovers upset as medical doctor claims their favourite meal can cause cancer

Kenkey lovers upset as medical doctor claims their favourite meal can cause cancer

How to choose Latin Ballroom Dance Shoes: A complete guide

How to choose Latin Ballroom Dance Shoes: A complete guide

Colour blindness: All you need to know about people who can't see colours

Colour blindness: All you need to know about people who can't see colours

7 strange things cats do and what they mean

7 strange things cats do and what they mean

Fresh Start: 30 short and uplifting prayers to bless your week ahead

Fresh Start: 30 short and uplifting prayers to bless your week ahead

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT