ADVERTISEMENT

Crisis deepens as US court backs Chinese firm in $70m arbitration dispute against FG

It was gathered that tension escalated in 2016 when Zhongshan accused the Ogun State government of attempting to terminate its appointment and replace the free trade zone management.

This ruling authorises the Chinese firm to impose final charging orders on two residential properties owned by Nigeria in the United States. [Getty Images]

This ruling further complicates the Nigerian government's efforts to contain the fallout from an international dispute that has already led to the attempted seizure of Nigerian assets in Europe.

On August 9, a US appellate court confirmed the decision of the US District Court for the District of Columbia, allowing Zhongshan Fucheng to enforce the $70 million arbitration award.

This ruling authorises the Chinese firm to impose final charging orders on two residential properties owned by Nigeria in the United States.

ADVERTISEMENT

The case stems from a 2010 agreement between Zhongshan Fucheng and the Ogun State government in Nigeria. Under this agreement, the Chinese firm, through its parent company, Zhuhai Zhongfu Industrial Group Co. Ltd, acquired rights to develop a free trade zone.

However, tensions escalated in 2016 when Zhongshan accused the Ogun State government of attempting to terminate its appointment and replace the free trade zone management.

Zhongshan subsequently initiated an investment treaty arbitration against Nigeria under the China-Nigeria Bilateral Investment Treaty (BIT).

ADVERTISEMENT

The arbitration panel ruled in favour of Zhongshan, awarding the company approximately $70 million in compensation. Despite Nigeria's efforts to plead state immunity, the US courts have consistently ruled against the country.

High Court Judge Sara Cockerill had earlier dismissed Nigeria's immunity claim, citing the Nigerian government's abuse of appeal timelines.

Judges Patricia Millett and Julianna Childs of the US Court of Appeals held that the arbitration award is enforceable under the New York Convention in their majority ruling.

They noted that the dispute involved "persons" with a legal commercial relationship, and thus, Nigeria was not protected by sovereign immunity under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA).

"For the foregoing reasons, we hold that the final award is enforceable under the New York convention because it arose out of differences between 'persons' that share a legal, commercial relationship," the judges stated, according to Daily Trust.

ADVERTISEMENT

However, the dissenting judge, Gregory Katsas, argued that the New York Convention did not intend to include sovereign nations under the definition of "persons."

Katsas contended that Ogun State's actions should not be attributed to the Nigerian government and that the arbitration award pertains to Nigeria's sovereign acts under public international law.

JOIN OUR PULSE COMMUNITY!

Unblock notifications in browser settings.
ADVERTISEMENT

Eyewitness? Submit your stories now via social or:

Email: eyewitness@pulse.ng

Recommended articles

Adelabu reveals causes of frequent grip collapses after receiving committee report

Adelabu reveals causes of frequent grip collapses after receiving committee report

Harris concedes defeat, calls to congratulate Trump on election victory

Harris concedes defeat, calls to congratulate Trump on election victory

How Nigeria plans to become a trillion-dollar economy – Dabiri-Erewa

How Nigeria plans to become a trillion-dollar economy – Dabiri-Erewa

Road accidents claim more passengers’ lives than drivers – FRSC

Road accidents claim more passengers’ lives than drivers – FRSC

Lagos seals Redeemed, Cele churches; recreational centres over noise pollution

Lagos seals Redeemed, Cele churches; recreational centres over noise pollution

Emir Sunusi lauds Tinubu over release of arrested minors

Emir Sunusi lauds Tinubu over release of arrested minors

Tinubu directs national flag to be flown at half mast in honour of Lagbaja

Tinubu directs national flag to be flown at half mast in honour of Lagbaja

Iran plays down importance of Trump's victory, voices readiness for confrontation

Iran plays down importance of Trump's victory, voices readiness for confrontation

We sought audience with Kemi Badenoch a few times but she ignored us - Abike Dabiri

We sought audience with Kemi Badenoch a few times but she ignored us - Abike Dabiri

Pulse Sports

Most Beautiful: Sha'Carri Richardson turns up with 'boyfriend' Christian Coleman for Cowboys-Falcons game receiving loud ovation

Most Beautiful: Sha'Carri Richardson turns up with 'boyfriend' Christian Coleman for Cowboys-Falcons game receiving loud ovation

'Thank you Lookman' - Nigerians appreciate CAF POTY nominee for helping Osimhen get 'revenge' against Napoli

'Thank you Lookman' - Nigerians appreciate CAF POTY nominee for helping Osimhen get 'revenge' against Napoli

Victor Osimhen reaches out to ex-Super Eagles striker Ighalo after heartbreaking loss

Victor Osimhen reaches out to ex-Super Eagles striker Ighalo after heartbreaking loss

Our Happy Place: Noah Lyles and Junelle Bromfield become home owners

Our Happy Place: Noah Lyles and Junelle Bromfield become home owners

Heartbreak for Augustine Eguavoen as Super Eagles lose key defender to 'difficult injury' for 4 months

Heartbreak for Augustine Eguavoen as Super Eagles lose key defender to 'difficult injury' for 4 months

See humility — Fans compare N’Golo Kante to Vinicius Jr. after Al-Ittihad star stopped to clean up pitch in middle of a match

See humility — Fans compare N’Golo Kante to Vinicius Jr. after Al-Ittihad star stopped to clean up pitch in middle of a match

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT