- I've been using an Apple MacBook Air for about six months and I've found that keyboard isn't all that great.
- But compared with a manual typewriter from the the 1960s, the MacBook keyboard is a miracle of modern technology.
- I've owned a number of Apple laptops, however, and the latest keyboard is probably my least favorite a far cry from the keyboard I remember most fondly, on an ancient iBook G4.
- Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories .
ADVERTISEMENT
I compared a new MacBook Air with a manual typewriter from the 1960s and my favorite Apple laptop of all time to see if the MacBook's controversial keyboard is as bad as everyone says (AAPL)
The "butterfly" keyboard on Apple laptops has been resoundingly criticized.
Typewriter vs. MacBook Air
ADVERTISEMENT
Hate your MacBook butterfly keyboard? You aren't alone complaints about the keyboard are all over the internet, and at Business Insider we've found the design to be wanting.
I've been using a new MacBook Air for about six months, and while typing on the keyboard is super-fast, I've also noted a decline in accuracy from the desktop keyboard I had been using, and from Apple laptops I've owned in the past.
As it turns out, I also possess the state-of-the-art for portable word processing from the 1960s: a Smith-Corona manual typewriter, which I still often use. I thought it might be both amusing an illuminating to compare that heavy-duty, hard-work keyboard with what modern technology has given us.
ADVERTISEMENT
So here we go:
Heres my new MacBook Air.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
Its exceptionally slim.
ADVERTISEMENT
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
The 13-inch laptop with a Retina display is a sophisticated piece of 21st-century technology that unfortunately has one glaring flaw ...
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
ADVERTISEMENT
... Its controversial butterfly keyboard.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
My BI colleague's Antonio Villas-Boas and Lisa Eadicicco have been all over the complaints about the keyboards.
I gather that Apple is preparing to phase them out, according to the latest reports.
ADVERTISEMENT
There are other quirks. My new MacBook uses a USB-C charger gone is the magnetic MagSafe charging port.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
And the overall lack of old-school ports means that I need a special adapter to provide an ethernet hookup and to connect a printer or charge an iPhone.
BusinessInsider USA Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Matt DeBord/BI
There is, however, a headphone jack.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
Honestly, I havent found the keyboard to be that bad. But it probably is the least accurate, worst-feeling Apple laptop keyboard Ive ever used. I can see why folks are complaining.
ADVERTISEMENT
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
But how does it compare with the laptop of the 1960s?
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
ADVERTISEMENT
Behold, my beloved Smith-Corona manual typewriter. Made in England!
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
Smith-Corona as a brand dates to the late 19th century, and through the 20th until the 1990s, when it effectively vanished. I cant be sure, but I think my typewriter was made between 1965-1969.
BusinessInsider USA Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Matt DeBord/BI
Its the Corsair Deluxe model, a lightweight plastic manual that was designed to be affordable and portable.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
Its certainly not MacBook Air thin, but it was quite svelte for the period.
ADVERTISEMENT
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
Obviously, it has no use for USB-C charging.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
ADVERTISEMENT
And I dont need to connect a printer.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
I do, however, need to use a pad to keep it from slipping around on my desk.
BusinessInsider USA Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Matt DeBord/BI
I unpack this typewriter for various artsy projects, as well as when I just want to quickly write something up. I used typewriters for years before computers, so I have the process down pat. You first roll paper into the machine.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
It has these wing-like bars to support each sheet.
ADVERTISEMENT
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
And once you have the paper rolled onto the plate and everything lined up, you lock the carriage and bring down the guide to hold the paper in place.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
ADVERTISEMENT
The typebars rise in response to keystrokes and hammer letters and numbers into the ribbon. Its all rather noisy.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
No fonts, but you can change colors, if you have the correct style of ribbon.
BusinessInsider USA Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Matt DeBord/BI
Whack the carriage return lever to set the left margin and youre rockin and rollin like an analog throwback boss.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
The ERROR CONTROL function is sort of cool: it allows you to drop a letter between letters youve already typed, to fix mistakes.
ADVERTISEMENT
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
My Smith-Corona uses ribbon spools that I can still find on Amazon. But it is slightly dirty work to charge them.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
ADVERTISEMENT
The way it works with typewriters is that you make a small stack of fresh paper to one side ...
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
... And transfer the typed sheets to the other side when youre finished.
BusinessInsider USA Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Matt DeBord/BI
No cutting and pasting or spellcheck, much less Grammarly. The tools of the typewritten manuscript editing trade are pens, pencils, staples, scissors, and tape.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
Im one of those typists who always uses two sheets at a time one sheet absorbs the impact of the typebars and keeps the platen from getting beaten up.
ADVERTISEMENT
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
So what about the keyboard?
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
ADVERTISEMENT
Well, there aint no butterflies here! The truth is that typing on the MacBook Air, as Im doing now, goes at Mach speed compared with the manual typewriter. BUT because you have to think carefully about what youre writing with the Smith-Corona, and you have to apply some serious muscle, I think you make fewer errors.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
Its clearly no contest. Even the controversial Apple keyboard beats out the manual typewriter. That said, Ive always felt that I do my best writing on the typewriter. Its both more meditative and more physically demanding. A real workout!
BusinessInsider USA Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Matt DeBord/BI
Meanwhile, once I wrapped up the typewriter-MacBook comparo, I figured I should haul out my favorite Apple keyboard.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
There are lots of stickers on this thing.
ADVERTISEMENT
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
Its an iBook G4! I think I got it in 2004. The keyboard always felt just about perfect to me, and although the laptop isnt powered up here, it still works and I still use it when I want to do some distraction-free writing.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
ADVERTISEMENT
The G4 was the last of Apples iBook lineup, which was replaced by the MacBook.
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
Its not thin, exactly, but it does have a CD slot.
BusinessInsider USA Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Matt DeBord/BI
And a whole mess of ports!
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
As you can see, I used the heck out of this machine. If I can keep it running, it could become to my descendants what my Smith-Corona Corsair Deluxe is to me.
ADVERTISEMENT
BusinessInsider USA Images
Matt DeBord/BI
See Also:
- Critics are calling Apple's latest refreshed laptops a 'much-needed upgrade' here's what they have to say about the new MacBook Air and MacBook Pro
- You should change this one setting on your iPhone if you want better battery life
- Calling all app developers: We want to know what your job is really like
SEE ALSO: I upgraded my standing desk after a making the switch from sitting and it was a great move
FOLLOW BUSINESS INSIDER AFRICA
ADVERTISEMENT
Recommended articles
How SafeHamsters unlocks the potential of crypto betting| Insider Tips
A look into the diverse tax reforms being implemented across Africa
Dubai firm to lend South Sudan $12.9 billion in exchange for 20 years oil repayment
China dethrones USA as the most influential global power in Africa: Report
Major African economies expecting inflation ease into next year, except Nigeria
10 African countries with the lowest price changes in household commodities
Dangote refinery outranks Europe's 10 largest refining facilities
Africa may just have the lowest level of cyber threats compared to other regions