While they might go on to retain the league title, not one person felt they could replicate the magic they performed barely months ago.
Who wins the Serie A?
"Inter," senior editor Solace Chukwu said without thinking twice. "Inter ran Milan mighty close for the title last season, but ultimately failed to retain their crown.
"This time around, I think they will return to the top of the tree. They have recruited well, with the return of Romelu Lukaku in particular, set to give them a major boost.
"However, arguably more important is the fact that I think AC Milan will take a step back this season, and Juventus will be just unable to make up the ground.
"Inter have not been weakened, save for the loss of Ivan Perisic," he continued. "Therefore are in the best position to take advantage."
While reporters David Ben and Tosin Abayomi corroborated Solace's pick for the Scudetto, editor Joba Ogunwale had everyone filling the room with giggles, and then in seconds, commanded interest with his bold call.
"I think Roma will win the title," he started. "I know Juventus and Inter have better squads, but I think Jose Mourinho is cooking something great with the signings he has made this summer.
"It will be difficult, but I don't think Inter are as strong as they were two seasons ago while Juventus may struggle with chemistry."
What will Serie A's top 4 look like?
Tosin: "Inter Milan recruited well after narrowly missing out. The return of Lukaku is big and his goals take them over the top, and then comes Roma, finish it with AC Milan and then Juventus."
Joba: "I don't expect AC Milan to retain their title because they have been poor in the transfer market but I expect them to finish in the top four alongside Roma, Inter and Juventus."
David: "Obviously, Inter as first. Juventus are good money for second before I can call AC Milan. Roma will finish in fourth place."
Solace: "Inter, Juventus, AC Milan and Roma - Juventus have bolstered the squad really well, and while I believe this will give them a significant boost, I still have concerns over whether Max Allegri's football can still work at the top level.
"However, they should finish ahead of Milan, who I tip to lose some ground. Their title win was such a feel-good story, and while I admire them for sticking to the strategy that got them there, the point of that success should have been to take a step forward, not mark time. Roma should round up the top four. They've also done good business, especially with the mercurial Paulo Dybala, and they have Jose Mourinho, so I pick them to pip a much weakened Napoli to a Champions League spot."
As the Serie A kicks off this weekend, who do you think will win the Serie A?